Skip to main content

Blocks in the East, physical product review

The quest for a strategy East Front game continues. This is more of a product review, as I only played 3 turns out (almost the complete short Barbarossa scenario) and decided I wasn’t motivated enough to go on.

BITE is not a good example of professional graphic or product design. A pretty good indicator of this is the box cover which has nice art, but you can see the pixels as it is not 200dpi. It looks slightly cheap and this is my general feeling with this game. The map art is garish and in some areas and some parts such as the Siberia box look downright terrible with clashing colours and badly placed icons.
Not only does it fail the form test, but also the function. Key charts are printed on the board. Often this is fine, but here they are not facing either player, and are difficult to see from a sitting position. The end result will be playing standing with a craned neck until you have them memorised.
Finally, and probably the biggest health warning on this game is the block density. There are a lot of blocks with this game and you can in theory stack 4 in a hex. Unfortunately the hexes can barely hold four blocks, let alone any moving in to attack. This has several consequences, first combat is slow as you have to get blocks out and move them around, second unless you know this game well you are going to forget where your blocks are and what you are doing. There is a forest of tightly packed wood in front of you that crowds out any narrative and makes decision making a process of wading through treacle. Finally you cannot see the icons on the board. A key part of the advanced rules game is counting the tiny factory icons or oil wells to determine your resources, this is going to be difficult if these are hidden under a forest of blocks.

Mid-way through turn 2, I stacked the air and invading units on top of defenders to fit them in some hexes.


The game itself is ok, without extensive play I cannot really give it a fair shake. The block system is fairly standard, the turns are igougo, and you throw fists full of dice and rotate units for damage. The basic game is very simple, it doesn’t even really use the HQs for anything of note. The advanced game plus the optional rules is a little more complex and has an interesting looking accounting system which forces you to manage tech levels, factories, and oil reserves. However given the bad information design I wonder whether this would just add to the mental mess.


I’m not sure where my Goldilocks zone is for unit density. I felt that No Retreat the Russian Front was too sparse and abstract, but here there are too many units given the kinds of decisions I was making. This game might work for some, if you can get past the presentation. This is a 2012 game however, given the vast history of war board games, I’m not sure bad presentation is excusable anymore, particularly at this price point. There are more east front games out there than I can shake a stick at, so why would I grind fun out of this one rather than selling up and moving somewhere else?

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

Quick Looks: Won by the Sword

Won by the Sword went down like Fat Man over Nagasaki on most wargame forums when released by GMT back in 2014. Lots of misprints on the components and errors in the rules gave it a bad rep to such an extent that GMT decided to bail it out with a patch. James and I have played a couple of games reworked version, it still rides like a bike with two missing gears but its probably the most innovative and insightful design to hit the scene in the past 10 years.


The rules; they work fine for the most part, James is clearer on the gaps than me, he reads them, I'm the opponent. What I will say is that they work if you can put the daddy pants on and make common sense decisions to fill any minor gaps.



Forage; Some games are about movement, some about concentration of fire, some moral, others unit composition, some bluff or even supply routes. Won by the Sword is about burning peoples villages and taking all their food, mostly just to stop your opponent doing it. This is the 30 years war, a…

Wilderness War is probably the best CDG (review)

One attribute of a good war game is that it opens up rather than narrows down the more you play it. Each time you play you see there is more strategic depth than you thought there was. When I first started playing Wilderness War, a card driven wargame design (CDG) on the French Indian War by Volko Runke, I thought it was simply a case of the British building a large kill stack and marching it up the Hudson and the French trying to get enough victory points (vps) from raiding to win before the inevitable. The outcome would likely be decided by card play and who got the reinforcement cards when they needed them.



Four games later I have realised that this is not the case. Yes the British will sometimes win by marching a big army up the Hudson and sieging out Montreal, but a lot of the time things will play out quite differently. Maybe the French strike first, perhaps the British realise that going up the Hudson is going to be a slog try another route. Either way the players of both sides…

Quick Looks: Next War Taiwan

If there is a series for hex and counter hipsters at the moment it is Next War games by Mitch Land and Gene Billingsley. Kev Sharp's been blogging it 1, 3MA have been talking about it 2, these drunken reprobates have been playing it 3, two of my friends have picked up Next War India Pakistan 4, one of whom as his first hex and counter game. When I first saw the GMT Next War series with Next War Korea a few years back, I passed on it because it was pricey and I thought future wars were boring. I thought these things because I was a fool. I'm not entirely sure why the series has become popular, as speculative future wars seems like a hard sell but the continued releases (now three soon four) and the quality of the product seem to have carried it into the wargamer consciousness if not the popular.


Next War Taiwan depicts an invasion of Taiwan by mainland China sometime in the near future. I say sometime because the game has no fluff text paragraphs, opting instead to insert a few…