I have played a couple of games of this now and watched one more. Not an expert but enough to share my opinion. It’s mixed I have enjoyed my games and will enjoy several more but I would caution the general recommendation for this rule set that gets chucked out regularly on reddit when anyone asks for a medieval or ancients ruleset. Hannibal surveys the field from behind his gallic infantry I will stick the boot in first then end on the positives. As a simulationist by preference this game is nonsense. A generalist ruleset is going to struggle to represent the nuances of warfare in a specific era. I should not be surprised that the way elephants are used is not that similar to their historical deployment, or that running three lines of republic romans is a bad idea however I’m not sure that these rules represent any ancient or medieval warfare in a particularly meaningful way. Let’s start with the victory conditions. Your army routs when you lose roughl
Histories & Fantasies